Designing an embedded application

ChibiOS/RT offers a variety of mechanisms and primitives, often it is better to focus on a single approach for the system design and use only part of the available subsystems.
When designing your application you may choose among several design alternatives.

Single threaded superloop

Correct, single thread, it is not mandatory to use the multithreading features of the OS. You may choose to implements everything as a complex state machine handled in the main thread alone. In this scenario the OS still offers a variety of useful mechanisms:

  • Interrupt handling.
  • Virtual Timers, very useful in state machines in order to handle time triggered state transitions.
  • Power management.
  • Event Flags and/or Semaphores as communication mechanism between interrupt handlers and the main superloop.
  • I/O queues.
  • Memory allocation.
  • System time.

In this configuration the kernel size is really minimal, everything else is disabled and takes no space. You always have the option to use more threads at a later time in order to perform separate tasks.

Message passing

In this scenario there are multiple threads in the system that never share data, everything is done by exchanging messages. Each thread represents a service, the other threads can request the service by sending a message.
In this scenario the following subsystems can be used:

  • Synchronous Messages.
  • Mailboxes (asynchronous message queues).

The advantage of this approach is to not have to deal with mutual exclusion, each functionality is encapsulated into a server thread that sequentially serves all the requests.
For example, you can have the following scenario:

  • A buffers allocator server.
  • A disk driver server.
  • A file system server.
  • One or more client threads.

Example: Note that the threads should not exchange complex messages but just pointers to data structures in order to optimize the performance. Also note that a thread can be both client and server at the same time, the FS service in the previous scenario for example.

Threads sharing data

This is the most common scenario, several threads have access to both their private data and shared data. Synchronization happens with one of the mechanisms described in the ”ChibiOS/RT mutual exclusion guide”.

Mixed

All the above approaches can be freely mixed in a single application but usually it is preferred to choose a way and consistently design the system around it. The OS is a toolbox that offers a lot of tools but you don't have to use them all necessarily.

 
chibios/guides/design_guide.txt · Last modified: 2011/10/03 20:52 by giovanni
 
Except where otherwise noted, content on this wiki is licensed under the following license:GNU Free Documentation License 1.3